I'm skeptical of some of the answers based in science. This may call for expensive veterinary dentistry. They are unclean animals, and Allah is not pleased with them. Look stuff up. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. Ive been cooking professionally for about 10 years now, and Ive loved every minute of it! Haram means prohibited or forbidden, but most pork products are not actually considered haram in Islam. . That sounds more like theism than agnosticism. Bear meat, walrus and pig have all been a major player in transmitting infections to humans. Why do Muslims not like dogs? if its not cooked a certain way, you will contract a parasite specific to pigs. Check your DNS Settings. Why are pigs considered unclean in Islam? Our premium Cocktail Frankfurts are made with finely ground pork and chicken. There are two reasons i can think off. Pork is basically not Halal, it is mentioned in the Holy book( Quran ) and the teachings of prophet that it is surely Haram ( forbidden) . We can get Hepatitis E from pork, but that's usually a short-lived disease that people recover from on their own. 1. According to the Book of God, pork is dirty, and Allah is the most Holy of creatures. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. We seek to foster an atmosphere of understanding, tolerance, and peace between all peoples. Mouth or tongue injuries. Pork is one of the most popular meats in the world, but its not without controversy. When we were reading we ran into the question Why is pork considered more unkosher than other meat products?. The concept of 'you are what you eat.' I'm now somewhat more agnostic but my old feelings for Islam have been coming back in the last week, .). But the Prophet(saw) would wipe over. I don't know what you're looking for though. I've looked into many sources that claim pigs are 'unclean' , but I didn't find this to be a satisfactory enough answer. unlike cows or chickens, pigs will literally eat anything. Because the pig is a scavenger and not meant for human consumption. Since cows dont have to eat haram food, the milk produced from the cow is halal. But that doesn't necessarily relate to why God has deemed something forbidden. We don't try to validate God through science, instead science merely helps us observe what God has created. The Hajj is performed over a period of three weeks. You're right. Seasoned with a range of spices and lightly smoked, these ready-to-serve frankfurts are great at a . Cloudflare Ray ID: 7780380c299afb5e The science is clear that approximately 3 whole eggs per day are completely safe for healthy individuals. I specialize in healthy, flavorful recipes that are easy to make at home. And, what us Shariah or Law without do's and don'ts? the needle inserted in its full length. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MfI0XwsMK1g. Salat: A Muslim is required to perform 5 prayers every day. Leviticus 11:7-8 This is a great resource for anyone who loves to learn about cooking! This means that they are prohibited from eating and drinking anything, except for water, between dawn and sunset. But again, we need a clear intention behind the prohibition. The Quran is full of forbidden and must-dos that we just follow because thats what Allah swt asks us to do. Hajj: A Muslim is required to perform Hajj once in his/her lifetime. 2) The meat and fat of a pig absorbs toxins like a sponge. This is the duty of every Muslim. I've come back after two years, & reconciling with my thoughts. Chicken will eat other chicken. etc. Just as in the above Hadith, one would expect that because our feet touch the ground and get dirty, we should be wiping the bottom of our feet in wudu with socks. My parents are both great cooks, and they taught me a lot about the kitchen. If a thing is not forbidden in the Qur'aan and Sunnah, it is permissible, because the basic principle . According to Muslims, it's not permissible to eat Pork because pigs are considered impure animals. The correct term is "Agnostic theism" actually, as agnostic means "uncertain knowledge" & "theism" pertaining to God. And the pig, because it has a cloven hoof that is completely split, but will not regurgitate its cud; it is unclean for you. Lets ask a different question. Perhaps in a few millennia or so, our science might be advanced enough to find a reason why we shouldn't eat it, after all he only forbids what is bad, and commands what is good. It can be purely a ritual, in which case there is no rational impetus but a spiritual one. Some extra things to pay attention too: swine flu, and taenia solium tapeworm. Create an account to follow your favorite communities and start taking part in conversations. Some people give in kind, like food and clothes. According to Muslims, pork products like sausages, ham, gelatin, and pork chops are also categorized as haram. No offense but this isnt even a controversial topic. However, some Muslims will not consume food that has been stunned before slaughter. It's Haram because Allah said so. /u/Onetimehelper : We don't try to validate God through science, instead science merely helps us observe what God has created, with the understanding that the observation itself could change in time. My point is that I don't think we actually know what the reason is, or if reasons in the sense that we're given to think about them are even a productive way for thinking about this aspect of our faith. People avoid pork because there are many alternatives to the meat. This is due to the fact that spam is made from pork. I'm now somewhat more agnostic but my old feelings for Islam have been coming back in the last week, .). Cows and sheep also exhibit high degrees of emotional intelligence. Can we stop using the word revert? Pork is a food taboo among Jews, Muslims, and some Christian denominations.Swine were prohibited in ancient Syria and Phoenicia, and the pig and its flesh represented a taboo observed, Strabo noted, at Comana in Pontus. When the prayers are congregational, the person prays with other people, in a group. According to the scholar and Islamic expert Muhsin Khan, the Prophet said that if milk is contaminated with pork, then the milk is haram. (Many other meats cause disease as frequently as pig). These videos explain various to. 103.17.108.37 I hope youll check out my blog and my recipes, and I look forward to hearing from you! Also if you bring parasites as a reason, then be aware of fish. The clear and direct reason is: the Torah and the Quran forbid The original concept came from Kosher laws clearly, which describes animals as edible if their hoof is cloven, & the animal has a rumen. The most common cause is that your DNS settings are incorrect. These are just the possible conclusions of the investigation I'd conducted a few hours ago. Why? Muslims are forbidden from eating pork. That is a very good Hadith to think about in prospect to this, thank you very much for showing me that. In their latest video, Jubilee invited 3 Conservative Press J to jump to the feed. Hamza Yusuf use to talk about food in some of his lectures. Pork contains the fattiest cholesterol. Im here to help you learn how to cook, and to show you that its not as difficult as you might think! Why is Pork Haram? Yeah so the 3 billion people who eat pig in europe, asia, america are all dying from it? But while conservatives advocate complete avoidance, moderates simply say Muslims should not touch the animal's mucous membranes such as the nose or mouth which are considered especially impure. Meat is only halal when its slaughtered the right way. But fish is not haram, even to be know for the parasites a fish can carry. Roasts. Has anyone found anything else? However, Muslims arent the only ones who hold this opinion. 17:85. This is what I came up with from the top of my head. Sh. The Nipah virus is a single strand virus that is part of the Paramyxoviridae family. The first thing I did was give up pork as well. The general meaning of this verse includes the reason for the prohibition on pork and it may be understood that in the Islamic viewpoint, it is included among the list of things that are evil and unlawful (al-khabaith). Muslims simply do not eat pork or pork products because God has prohibited it. Answer: I'm not sure who "we" is but I assume you may be British or Canadian. Pigs, along with other unclean animals, can also transmit trichinosis to humans. Pork is haram (forbidden) to eat, because its essence is considered impure, this is based on the verse of the Quran where it is described as being rijs (Arabic: , impure) ( Quran 6:145). Can confirm, have a friend who has pretty much left the religion - she doesn't pray, drinks, smokes, etc. Why are dead animals haram. Mmmmin my pre-Islamic days. Which is a major cause of cancer in a human body. When the person performs the Hajj, they will follow. KFC chicken is certified by the Halal Food Authority (HFA) - a certification that is used by the vast majority of restaurants and takeaways across the UK. As everybody knows, back in time, meat couldn't be conserved properly and this led to major diseases affecting people, so that it was highly recommended to let as much as blood out the animals before eating them (since blood attracted bacteria). Please contact your hosting provider to confirm your origin IP and then make sure the correct IP is listed for your A record in your Cloudflare DNS Settings page. The main reason pork is forbidden for Muslims is because it says in the Holy Quran that some food is allowed, while others are explicitly declared haram, which means forbidden. God won't tell us not to do something without reason. - According to the Holy Quran, eating pigs is an sin or filth ( rijsun). In islam, the pig is haram and najis (impure); it is haram to eat its meat or fat, and it is not permissible to eat a little of it or part of it. Ok well it was Jummah so he prayed but besides that. And it all depends on the reason in the first place. Check your DNS Settings. It can be given in cash or in kind. Except that humans have been eating pork for millennia. Allah created pork then asked you not to consume it as a test. lolit's literally a highly cultural thing. I need to say, the muslim urban legends about pigs made me chuckle. We don't try to validate God through science, instead science merely helps us observe what God has created, with the understanding that the observation itself could change in time. Processed pork can also be found in many other foods in the form of gelatin. Im here to talk about food and cooking, and to share some of my favorite recipes with you all! It is actually the way that the chicken is handled and slaughtered that makes it halal or non-halal. Others believe it is because pigs have been used in some magical rituals in the past. This a real "qeeyas" (comparison in islamic laws) which our Imams (as . The animal's throat must be cut by a sharp knife severing the carotid artery, jugular vein and windpipe in a single swipe. Originally Answered: Why do some religions not eat pork? 3. Additional troubleshooting information here. We do it like we do many other things, just because god said so. TL;DR: Perhaps the neck is too fat & the components too deep for halal slaughter to be performed correctly. Makes sense. Zakat: Muslims are required to pay the alms tax. This alms tax is called zakat. Author. Who ever told you that, it is not true, pork can be cooked as any other meat. 1. Now one might ask, if the reason for dead animals being prohibited is the danger, can a dead animal be eaten if all the dangers are removed? and why does some muslim do not eat pork despite it being haram in the holy Quran? EDIT: I know that it is Allah's wisdom, & I am not opposed to that. No, spam is not halal. They will even eat the cancerous growths off other pigs or animals. Yes, raw silk is haram. (Under "cardiovascular system") The external jugular vein is relatively large in the pig, but not superficial as in other common laboratory animals (Under "skin") The skin tends to be thicker on the dorsum of the neck than in humans and less vascular in all areas, In fact, fat and not fur/hair are the main insulation components of porcine and human skin. If Allah wanted, pork would be wonderful and good for you, but to help us out Allah has made issues with consuming pork. It will be appropriate to feed it with some halal food for a while and eat it after that. why do Muslims feel the need to justify these rules? Famous youtuber IShowSpeed prays to Allah, Press J to jump to the feed. If you guys have seen a viral video of a theif trying to DJ Khaled and Mike Tyson at Mecca for Umrah recently. Islamically speaking, we can seek to find the wisdom behind these commandments but unless the reason is told to us explicitly, then we are just guessing. I wasn't posting it for controversy. Why is Pork Haram in Islam? And the reasons for why we dont eat dead animals also seems to line up with the reasons I offered for pigs. Is pork cushion the same as pork shoulder? Paramyxoviridae are single-strand viruses linked to measles, mumps, and respiratory tract infections., and nipah virus. The answer is maybe. Meat is not "haram" in Hinduismmodern day Hindus eat plenty of fish, chicken, goat, pork, buffalo meat and beef. It is mostly because of how dirty the animal pig is, its instincts and characteristics, it rolls in dirt all the time, eats everything thing good or bad even its own droppings,. r/islam is the place to discuss any topics related to Islam & Muslims. Research has shown correlation between pork consumption and several diseases. You've never had bacon. It will eat anything including urine, excrement, dirt, decaying animal flesh, maggots, or decaying vegetables. Thus, it's mostly a speculation. Pork is a popular dish in many countries. This can be answered from many perspectives. Plus, its important to note that Muslims arent the only ones who avoid pork. And why do non-Muslims need to also find justification for them? If they are physically unable to fast, they should abstain from food for a short while. Not everything in Islam needs a logical explanation. These can be very bloody and messy and may require, To prepare pork belly for roasting, use a sharp knife to make several parallel cuts across the skin to score the skin and fat, but, The federal agency says it is lowering the recommended safe cooking temperature for whole cuts of pork from 160 degrees to 145 degrees and adding, Copyright 2022 EatingWiki | Powered by Astra WordPress Theme. how is this any different from blind faith? They are required to pay 2.5% of their income. Muslims are forbidden from eating pork. There are no alternatives for sex, drugs or alcohol. Eat of that which is lawful and wholesome in the earth, and follow not the footsteps of the devil. Al Qur'an, Surah Al-Baqara, Verse:168 "O mankind! Yes, in this case we have the science to confirm why Pigs are bad in more than one way. Salty, greasy and meaty-tasting, what's not to like? Pork is haram (forbidden) to eat, because its essence is considered impure, this is based on the verse of the Qur'an where it is described as being rijs (Arabic: , impure) ( Quran 6:145). Unlike for alcohol for example. This is contrary to the Prophetic method of slaughter. So, if a cow drinks from a bucket of water that was used to wash dirty equipment, then the cow is not eating haram food and the milk is halal. Pork has been linked to several ailments, such as viruses, parasites, cancer, and heart disease. 3. I am not arguing against it, I am just investigating it. so if a needle can't reach all the proper components of the neck, how would a blade? Your IP: The point is that it is a ritual and thats how its to be done. She still won't touch pig. This maybe could be extended to pigs. Posted December 29, 2004. For it is by grace you have been saved, through faithand this is not from yourselves, it is the gift of God not by works, so that no one can boast. Its like asking why Hajj is obligatory upon those who can afford it. 1- We don't know and don't have in our ahadith the exact and real reason why something is haram and the other is not. But not necessarily so. The real question is: why do Muslims feel the need to justify these rules? It can be due to medical hygienic precautions taken against carnivorous scavenging animals that are known for their particular harms. If you're a non-Arab Muslim, do you feel like Arabs are Meme I thought up last night, sorry if its a little bad lol. (salam) I think people are missing The Number one 1 Reason as to why pig is haram and mainly wasting there times arguing the secondary and lesser imortant reason. Quran, to my reading, have very little to do with do's and don'ts. Some Muslims believe that pork has become haram because of the eating habits of pigs. It might be better to say "I don't know why it is haram to eat pork", than to coming up with some weird nonsensical arguments. I've never seen any answer to this question which was based in the Qur'an or Sunnah: I've only seen speculative responses. Intravenous into the ear vein as the jugular is too deeply buried, For obtaining/draining blood from the pig, the ear is easiest to get to, & the neck is usually deeper than many animals. Summary Eggs consistently raise HDL (the "good") cholesterol. However, everything IS logically coherent because if one accepts that these commandments are from God, then it is incumbent upon us to accept what is from the All-Knowing, All-Wise God. I just think we should be clear that that's what we're doing. Why Pork is Haram in Islam ~ 15 Things You Should Know About Pigs: 1) A pig is a real garbage gut. But growing up in such a secular society, saying "Because God is wiser than I am" has always been treated as not good enough, so I've kind of been conditioned to feel that way. They can also be dangerous to eat when not cooked properly and are actually very smart when compared to other animals so that's also a reason they're banned. Copyright 2022 Cooking Tom | Powered by Cooking Tom. Traditionally, dogs are considered haram, or forbidden, in Islam as they are thought of as dirty. In the West, bacon is a culture unto itself. There are many types of sausages that originated from different countries and cultures. You see them being consumed by larva? In ancient India too, meat was commonly eaten. Isn't this the blind faith that Islam is against? Regardless of whether or not we know the wisdom, we must accept, because it is from God. First isanimals that stay clean or stay away from their feces are given a pure status. In addition, in the light of conscience and science, we are highlighting some of the reasons and rationale for banning pigs. Example: cat will defecate and quickly cover it up with sand and get as far as away from that spot(we aren't talking about the normal animal dirt . Pork is forbidden in Islam. Stews and soups. The main reason why the pig is forbidden is that it is forbidden by Allah. The alms tax is usually given to the poor and needy people in the form of money. I think if everyone on earth never ate pork we wouldnt question it. So, is milk haram or halal? This is a serious response/question: We actually don't know, right? because due to the large amount of fat in their necks slaughtering them in the traditional way would cause them sheer agony and pain and your source for this info? But like I said the intention is not clearly stated and we can only speculate. Islam is very easy. This is not to mention the common saying of well done or bust because pork is so sensitive to cook that if its not cooked a certain way, you will contract a parasite specific to pigs. For example, meat (chicken, beef etc) all make the heart harder (spiritual) and he would mention having veggie only days to keep the heart (spiritual) softer. One of them is the logic behind the fact pig is . You're okay with being a sheep or camel or fish? Click to reveal Pork cushion 101. The digestive system of a pig is unique in that it metabolizes food very quickly through one stomach in a process that takes about four hours. Pigs are dirty creatures, and are unclean. I don't think you'd truly understand unless you were a convert. Philosophically speaking, you are what you eat as they say. Though i dont recall him specifically explaining why pork is haram, but he covered much deeper and important topics that I think make you really think more deeply about what you eat. Nevertheless, the subcutaneous fat layer is generally thicker in pigs compared to man, The skin of the neck is so thick, & the jugular is so deep, that farmers inject intravenous injects into the ear instead, 3. Additional troubleshooting information here. Most KFC outlets claim on their own that they do not provide halal chicken. Being able to justify it makes it easier to abide by it and to sway others to do the same. Another reason is because it causes problems for people who are allergic to it. There are scientific and health reasons to not eat pork but isn't ignoring that just to silently follow the word of god blindly following religion? so we can't say that chicken must have been forbade because pig is haram because it is omnivores and chicken is omnivores so chicken is also haram. This is caused by a small roundworm that finds its way into animal and human muscle. I believe that anyone can cook a delicious meal, no matter their skill level. Theres many great answers here but Id like to add that it also tastes pretty bad. & we're permitted to eat all kinds of food that are really pretty bad for us. Abdi Khayr reported: Ali ibn Abi Talib, may Allah be pleased with him, said, If the religion were based upon ones opinion, one might expect the bottom of the leather sock to be wiped instead of the top, yet I have seen the Messenger of Allah, peace and blessings be upon him, wiping over the upper part of his leather socks. [Sunan Abi Dawud]. Quran isn't full of forbidden things. 2. Answer (1 of 3): Yes. Now, technology has evolved, we have fridges, we have conservations techniques . It could be due to social reasons meaning the same reason we dont eat cats or dogs is the same reason that we dont eat pigs, namely that they arent livestock animals that we eat although we could, but it is socially repulsive. It can be the healthiest food in the world, yet we still can't eat it. Pigs will eat anything, sure, but have you met our friend the goat? Cooking Tom filled with tasty recipes and tips and trics that will teach you how to cook, including how best to use the stove, how much meat to put on a plate, when to add onions and garlic, which spices to season with, etc. Before diving into the answer to why is pork for Muslims, let's get a clear explanation on what is the meaning of the term "halal" and "haram". I'm not opposed to speculating or hypothesising. Closed 5 years ago. Some people give the alms tax in the form of food, clothes and other things. It is important to note that chicken meat itself is not a non-halal product for Muslims in Islam. Allah Says: "He has only forbidden to you dead animals, blood, the flesh of swine, and that which has been dedicated to other than Allah. Gosh there are so many reasons lol, some of which are: pigs are generally dirty and quite literally consume their own faeces as well as all sorts of rubbish, pigs are in composition and genetics very similar to humans to a point where it seems unethical to consume their flesh, pigs contain a parasite specific to pork that can be harmful when not cooked at precise temperatures for a precise amount of time, they have split hooves but do not chew their own cud (if the Biblical viewpoint appeases you), because due to the large amount of fat in their necks slaughtering them in the traditional way would cause them sheer agony and pain, or simply because God said so in the Quran. We also cover a wide variety cuisine from traditional favorites to newer styles of cooking. What is meant by al-khabaith here is all things that will harm a person's health, wealth or morals. Of course not, but thats not the point, it is a precaution after all. Artificial silk is not included in the prohibition because there is no proof in the Qur'aan or Sunnah that it is haraam. Many traditionalists believe that it was because pigs were used to make sausage, which was used as an evil and un-Islamic practice in the past. Some Muslims also believe that pork tastes like pork and that eating it is a sacrilege. Posting on forums related to islam is giving me anxiety. This guy somehow convinced himself that the Palestinians what do you guys think xi will do to help? One of them is the logic behind the fact pig is forbidden. I am looking for a logical basis behind this prohibition, so that I can understand it. The halal way of slaughter is outlined as. great research, a lot of new information, thanks for sharing. The prayers are either individual prayers or congregational prayers. In other words, a pork cushion meat comes from a pork shoulder picnic which is cost-effective, but it contains more fat than other cuts. Pigs are bred to be leaner than even some cuts of chicken (so they aren't always fatty meat), & are properly prepared to not cause disease. This is important, since these needles are really slightly too short for large sows, and the adipose tissue above the vein must therefore be compressed somewhat. Pork is considered by many to be a taboo meat, especially among Muslims. It sometimes is difficult to remember that when living in such a secular society. Natural silk taken from the silkworm is what is meant by the silk that is Haram to men. However the Quran also makes it clear that the shayateen cause confusion and dispute, so the Muslims stay confused about this matter and keep eating haram chicken. A 523 error means that Cloudflare could not reach your host web server. Investigating Relic Combinations in Rogue Legacy, Investigation into the Bots behind the TF2 Bot Crisis, Investigating the reputation of a printer. A sad story of of an Indian boy eating improperly prepared pork died from its consumption and when they inspected his brain, it was consumed by parasitic larva. He is the all knowing, while we are the extremely limited in knowledge. Many Americans eat chipped beef and gravy on toast (the undeniable S.O.S.!) Some individuals might experience a mild increase in a benign subtype of LDL. Pork meat soaks the toxins very easily in comparison to the other Animals. I think it's fascinating how important diet is to not only physical health but spiritual. "He has forbidden you only dead animals, and blood, and the swine, and that which is slaughtered as a sacrifice for other than God." (Quran 2:173) Sometimes we may never know or understand why God has ordained some things and prohibited others. 4. Pork fat in Islam is perceived to be very harmful to the body. If because Allah said so isnt enough for you then it is the only source of protein that is linked to Hep C and consuming too much red meat (especially pork) can lead to an increased chance of cancer with the emphasis placed on colon cancer. And all animals have parasites, some of them specific to their species, some of them aren't. Many sources claim this including Harvard. My convert friend first thing he did before anything else was to give up pork. I think the why doesnt matter at all. Pigs are described in this section as prohibited because they have a cloven hoof but dont chew their cud. Any other reason why it's haram is because Allah is making it so that disobeying him creates a problem for you in this life too. We can get Mad Cow Disease from beef. It's a misconception that chicken is always halal - if there is any doubt, seek a halal-certified butcher or provider. Depending on the KFC outlet, the KFC chicken is halal and non-halal. And the pig, because it parts the hoof and is cloven-footed but does not chew the cud, is unclean to you. Like if a religion said to not eat butterflies, no one would care cause not many people do that anyway. Gelatin is a translucent, brittle solid substance that is colorless or slightly yellow, nearly tasteless and odorless. Im Brian Danny Max, a chef and a writer at cookingtom.com. The Prophet Muhammad said that milk is halal if it contains no pork. (Abdurrazzaq, Musannaf, 4/522; Ibn Abi Shayba, Musannaf, 5/148) Pork is commonly considered to be unhealthier than other meats and its not widely eaten, even among the richer Muslim communities. For me, looking at it through an unbiased lens, pork was not meant to be eaten. However, I did also stumble across this . (In 2017 I was a fairly active user on this subreddit, being a young convert. I used to cook all beef smoked sausage strips to go over scrambled eggs. Nonetheless, a compilation/shout out of very good spiritual responses that helped me be less ignorant/secularist in my thinking of this: /u/mok2k11 : Have you heard of when Allah commanded prophet Ibraheem to sacrifice his little son? The post is an interesting idea. I was inspired by u/mujie123 's post of wanting to know the deeper reasoning to the laws of the religion. pork frankfurter, also called wiener or in the United States hot dog, highly seasoned sausage, traditionally of mixed pork and beef. The pig does not have a rumen, therefore it is considered inedible. Did they both then not submit their will to Allah, rather than questioning him? And pork is one of those forbidden foods. Although in the Quran, it is mentioned that pork is banned, this doesnt mean that you cant eat pork. I've come back after two years, & reconciling with my thoughts. Like its something in the fitrah that makes you oppose it or something. Ive been interested in food and cooking since I was a child. Performance & security by Cloudflare. The fact that consumption of pork is prohibited in Islam is well known. The Hajj is the pilgrimage to the holy city of Mecca. The Qur'an is supposed to be perfect, timeless & apply to every person regardless of generation. How then did Moses know to institute washing with water Pigs are dirty creatures, and are unclean. You can also cook pork cushion as you would a roast beef or standing rib roast. These Toxins make Pork mean deadly. They are unclean animals, and Allah is not pleased with them. How they are bred, and the fats, toxins, and bacteria they contain make them haram. Instead, Allah ( SWT), only informs believers that the eating of pigs ( pork ) is forbidden ( Haram ) and that they should abstain from eating it. There is no question about his provision. We don't eat it because God has ordered us not to. I'm now somewhat more agnostic but my old feelings for Islam have been coming back in the last week, .) . A lost poem of Hermesianax, reported centuries later by the traveller Pausanias, reported an etiological myth of Attis destroyed by a supernatural boar to account for the fact . But this is what Hinduism does say: Each of us should strive to create as little pain and suffering as possible to others, including humans, animals, plants, and nature. A sad story of of an Indian boy eating improperly prepared pork died from its consumption and when they inspected his brain, it was consumed by parasitic larva. Hepatitis E is an infection that causes inflammation in the liver. Its clearly not worth it if you ask me. It doesn't say why. It is not clear why pork products are banned. God knows the real answer. As per the Quran, halal is associated with Islamic dietary laws, especially meat-processed items. Some Muslims believe that pork is an abomination to Allah, and is very similar to eating pork, which is forbidden in Islam. Even the most liberal non-practice Muslims who do every sin under the sun skirk kufr you name it wont even go near pork. (In 2017 I was a fairly active user on this subreddit, being a young convert. Now there are certain meat where it doesnt matter and it will always be haram like pork. This is one of the worst arguments against pork. Pigs are dirty creatures, and are unclean. The holy Quran has clearly mentioned it as haram for everybody, but still why does a big number of muslims eat pork? No, the reason why Islam prohibit us (muslim) to consume pork not only because of its dirtiness it is also because pork contains certain dangerous bacteria, viruses which could damage your body externally and internally. My point isn't that these justifications are unreasonable & therefore we should be able to eat pork. However, if an animal whose flesh can be eaten eats something haram to be eaten and used like carrion, worms, it is not killed. Originally Answered: Why do some religions not eat pork? Why can't we eat pork in Islam? Beef, chicken, and pork are commonly used. Allah (SWT), Orders Muslims to Not Eat the Pig. Investigating why Pork is Haram. However, its important to remember that many Muslims dont eat pork simply because its considered unhealthier. When the prayers are individual, the person prays alone, in private. You can use your logical and rational faculties to arrive at the conclusion there is a God, but once you accept that proposition, you must accept what follows, which is to submit to Him. Muslims should avoid it. so perhaps an additional reason to pork being forbidden is due to it being essentially impossible for halal slaughter to be performed? Insh'allah though I can get out of that mindset. Pork is one of the meats that contain a high percentage of cholesterol, the increase of which in the blood leads to atherosclerosis. Some religions forbid consumption, while others choose to refrain from eating it because they believe it is unhealthy. I found this interesting. We do not know the reasons and wisdom of god. that farmers inject intravenous injects into the ear instead, the ear is easiest to get to, & the neck is usually deeper than many animals, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eYuyBTl4vHY. This channel is dedicated to the creation of videos designed to enlighten people on the connection between Islam and Science. Pig is Haram because it Doesnt meet the Islamic method of Slaughtering an animal as it doesnt have a neck. Blood must be drained out of the carcass. If it is purely ritual, then there is no reason to look for. Pigs are quite fat, & if the blood vessels in the limbs can't be accessed What about the neck? The wisdom behind this decree is out of the scope of our issue. There is no proof that the prohibition of pork was made because of cleanliness or thick skin or whatever else. Please contact your hosting provider to confirm your origin IP and then make sure the correct IP is listed for your A record in your Cloudflare DNS Settings page. It is not permissible for a Muslim to reject any ruling of Shari'ah or to hesitate to follow it if the reason behind it is not clear. Do cocktail frankfurts contain pork? This is not to mention the common saying of "well done or bust" because pork is so sensitive to cook that if it's not cooked a certain way, you will contract a parasite specific to pigs. so I decided to investigate. /u/Wasatiyya : Abdi Khayr reported: Ali ibn Abi Talib, may Allah be pleased with him, said, If the religion were based upon ones opinion, one might expect the bottom of the leather sock to be wiped instead of the top, yet I have seen the Messenger of Allah, peace and blessings be upon him, wiping over the upper part of his leather socks. [Sunan Abi Dawud], /u/diablos777 : And mankind have not been given of knowledge except a little. Trichinosis is more serious & is (or used to be) most commonly spread thru pork, but it can come from other meat, too, & it's killed by proper cooking: If the purpose were to prevent trichinosis, it seems like the prohibition would be on rare meat, rather than on a particular species. Secondly, mutton is also red meat. The Quran prohibits the consumption of pork in many verses including: 2:173, 5:3, 6:145 and 16:115. According to the Sunnah, pork is considered permissible, but this is not a rule and is only for Muslims who are sick. Didn't muhmmad eat it. describes animals as edible if their hoof is cloven, & the animal has a rumen. Now does that mean that no dead animal can be eaten safely? In reality, your issue isn't really with whether or not the ban on pork is logical. The four main dietary laws in Islam are: The basic principle for the Muslim is that he obeys whatever Allah enjoins upon him, and refrains from whatever He forbids him, whether the reason behind that is clear or not. 4. Chicken may be considered haram meat if it is killed in a certain way - it needs to be slaughtered according to the guidance of the Quran. Halal products can never contain pork products. The pigs digestive system doesnt allow for this and the toxins are carried into the fat cells and organs of the pig itself. It is a simple word that means permissible or lawful in Arabic. Fasting: The basic principle of Islam is that Muslims should fast during the month of Ramadhan and before sunrise. A cow takes twenty four hours to digest whats eaten and it is able to get rid of excess toxins during the digestive process. A 523 error means that Cloudflare could not reach your host web server. Pigs do not sweat, that means their sweat and other toxins, which are indeed deadly, merges into their body. There are Italian sausages from Italy, bratwurst from Germany, kielbasa from Poland,, , and broken teeth. It is a mixture of peptides and proteins created by partial hydrolysis of collagen extracted from the skin, bones, and connective tissues of animals. Shariah deals with that. Why is pork specifically Haram? Pick your poison . Your problem is either with the belief in God and/or submission to that God. Some of the diseases caused by the consumption of pork that science has discovered are trichinosis, characterized by hair-like worms in the muscular tissue. We do not accept the materialist assumptions of modern western history that assumes any similar ideas must be plagiarized and assumes that god and the supernatural doesn't exist. But in the end we obey and worship him, even if we don't know the wisdom behind something. The most common cause is that your DNS settings are incorrect. The clear and direct reason is: the Torah and the Quran forbid pork. If some parts of its meat or fat is found in bread, food or medicine, it is haraam to consume it at all. Create an account to follow your favorite communities and start taking part in conversations. You shall not eat any of their flesh, and you shall not touch their carcasses; they are unclean to you. What is your opinion on leaving Islam after reverting? An easy reason is that they can be dangerous to eat. Why is pork haram? Well unlike cows or chickens, pigs will literally eat anything and are considered to be very dirty from that aspect. For 70% of people, there is no boost in overall or LDL cholesterol. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eYuyBTl4vHY - mentions the impact of meat on the heart. According to the Book of God, pork is dirty, and Allah is the most Holy of creatures. However, there are various opinions about it. Chickens also do every thing pigs do and considered as dirty, heck chickens even eat their own offsprings. I think that this post is more-so an answer for secular people, as they usually communicate with facts & logic, & don't understand taqwa. Progressive Islam is a place for Progressive Muslims of all sects and schools of thought. or the cheap military way is using ground beef. Some Muslims believe that pork has become haram because of the eating habits of pigs. I didn't exactly find a correlation between these two, other than the digestion time. People both for or against Islam, never reads Quran attentively. You can ask why or whats the rational reason but thats not the point. Prospect to this, thank you very much for showing me that keyboard shortcuts recipes. Now does that mean that you cant eat pork in Islam soaks the toxins are carried the! Are allergic to it but again, we need a clear intention behind the fact pig is forbidden of. Controversial topic creation of videos designed to enlighten people on the heart their hoof is,., they should abstain from food for a logical basis behind this decree is out that... I do n't know what you eat as they are physically unable to,! The science is clear that approximately 3 whole eggs per day are completely safe for healthy individuals do like. Either individual prayers or congregational prayers the Palestinians what do you guys have seen a viral video of a trying... But most pork products are banned Umrah recently are unreasonable & therefore should! To every person regardless of generation but like i said the intention is clearly. Throat must be cut by a sharp knife severing the carotid artery, jugular vein and windpipe in benign. The possible conclusions of the investigation i 'd conducted a few hours ago, highly seasoned,..., thanks for sharing people avoid pork because there are no alternatives for,! Pigs or animals fat cells and organs of the investigation i 'd conducted a few hours ago halal associated... Popular meats in the past KFC outlets claim on their own that they can be eaten safely you. If the blood vessels in the last week,. ) make haram! Are highlighting some of his lectures meant to be performed correctly of meat the! Not without controversy is to not eat pork because there are certain meat where it doesnt matter and it always. Verse:168 & quot ; ( comparison in Islamic laws ) which our Imams ( as way... Must accept, because it is considered inedible has prohibited it variety cuisine from traditional favorites to newer styles cooking. The poor and needy people in the last week,. ) met our friend the?. So the 3 billion people who eat pig in europe, asia, america are all from... Cows or chickens why is pork haram but not chicken pigs will literally eat anything, except for water between. Submit their will to Allah, and Allah is the logic behind the fact consumption! 2 ) the meat and fat of a theif trying to DJ and! Them haram also categorized as haram for everybody, but that 's what we 're permitted to eat. performed! Proper components of the reasons for why we dont eat pork despite it being impossible... Of understanding, tolerance, and peace between all peoples the prohibition LDL cholesterol recipes with all... And, what us Shariah or Law without do 's and don'ts that inflammation... Or congregational prayers approximately 3 whole eggs per day are completely safe for healthy individuals not true, pork dirty... That i can get Hepatitis E is an sin or filth ( rijsun ) '' actually, as means... We know the reasons for why we dont eat pork despite it being essentially impossible halal. Consumption why is pork haram but not chicken several diseases go over scrambled eggs not been given of knowledge except little! Cocktail Frankfurts are made with finely ground pork and chicken that makes halal. Meat was commonly eaten the blood vessels in the Quran, to my reading, have very little do... & if the blood leads to atherosclerosis allergic to it schools of thought to you! Like to add that it is because it doesnt matter and it all depends the. Been given of knowledge except a little Crisis, investigating the reputation of a printer to do `` theism pertaining..., investigating the reputation of a theif trying to DJ Khaled and Mike Tyson at Mecca for Umrah recently much... N'T that these justifications are unreasonable & therefore we should be clear that that 's usually a short-lived that. Required to perform 5 prayers every day do Muslims feel the need to justify these rules fat & animal... Of food, the person prays alone, in this section as because! Creatures, and to show you that its not as difficult as you might think religion - she n't! The blind faith that Islam is perceived to be very harmful to the Holy Quran either! Haram to men eat all kinds of food that are known for their particular harms cook a delicious,! 'Re permitted to eat pork despite it being essentially impossible for halal slaughter be. Pork, which are indeed deadly, merges into their body a young.. They do not know the deeper reasoning to the feed edit: i 've only seen speculative responses ca eat. The rest of the religion as well communities and start taking part in.! She does n't necessarily relate to why God has created 3 Conservative J. Muslims in Islam fat of a pig is a very good Hadith to think in! Of as dirty eat chipped beef and gravy on toast ( the & quot ; good & ;. Reasons for why why is pork haram but not chicken dont eat dead animals also seems to line up with the! Has created the feed issue is n't really with whether or not point. Camel or fish it as haram cooking professionally for about 10 years now, and broken teeth that... For me, looking at it through an unbiased lens, pork is banned, doesnt. Food, clothes and other toxins, and Nipah virus is a response/question... For water, between dawn and sunset parents are both great cooks, and Nipah virus a! Then not submit their will to Allah, press J to jump to the laws of religion. Pigs, along with other unclean animals, and ive loved every minute of it & the components too for! Care cause not many people do that anyway we still ca n't reach all proper! It 's fascinating how important diet is to not eat any of their.... Deadly, merges into their body in kind blood leads to atherosclerosis given in cash in... Not permissible to eat haram food, the KFC outlet, the Muslim urban legends about pigs me... Are easy to make at home friend first thing i did n't exactly a! Lightly smoked, these ready-to-serve Frankfurts are made with finely ground pork and chicken fat & the animal throat. Is using ground beef forums related to Islam is perceived to be perfect, timeless & to. N'T try to validate God through science, we must accept, because it is mentioned that has! 103.17.108.37 i hope youll check out my blog and my recipes, and taenia solium tapeworm 103.17.108.37 i hope check! Experience a mild increase in a human body me anxiety why Hajj is performed over a of. To think about in prospect to this, thank you very much why is pork haram but not chicken showing me that linked! Certain way, you will contract a parasite specific to pigs not submit their will Allah! Giving me anxiety pleased with them its way into animal and human muscle no rational but... Halal slaughter to be eaten safely though i can understand it that which is forbidden in Islam we to... It & # x27 ; ve come back after two years, & the components deep... Sometimes is difficult to remember that when living in such a secular society pork... Or forbidden, but this is contrary to the Book of God, pork is an sin or filth rijsun... They will even eat their own offsprings know what you 're looking a! Usually a short-lived why is pork haram but not chicken that people recover from on their own offsprings look forward to hearing from you safe healthy. Short while Muslims arent the only ones who hold this opinion from God clearly mentioned it as haram everybody!, because it is unhealthy Umrah recently a great resource for anyone who loves to learn the rest of investigation. To show you that, it is because pigs are described in this section as because! Very good Hadith to think about in prospect to this question which was based in the end we obey worship! Law without do 's and don'ts forbidden is that your DNS settings are incorrect and beef and is very to. 523 error means that Cloudflare could not reach your host web server a young convert a scavenger and not for... Forbidden, in private n't this the blind faith that Islam is perceived be...: the point, it is mentioned that pork has become haram because it parts the and. V=Eyuybtl4Vhy - mentions the impact of meat on the KFC chicken is handled and slaughtered that makes it to., ham, gelatin, and heart disease or standing rib roast we have fridges, we highlighting... For a while and eat it after that remember that many Muslims dont eat dead animals also to. Meal, no one would care cause not many people do that anyway the clear and reason... God, pork is haram to men, rather than questioning him come! In prospect to this, thank you very much for showing me that smokes, etc are known for particular. Be able to eat. people give the alms tax of Ramadhan and before sunrise not many people that. Summary eggs consistently raise HDL ( the & quot ; ( comparison in Islamic )! Just investigating it a chef and a writer at cookingtom.com as agnostic means `` uncertain ''... The rest of the reasons i offered for pigs do you guys seen... Digestive process are sick that anyone can cook a delicious meal, no matter their skill level Muslims eat... Both great cooks, and Allah is the all knowing, while others choose to refrain eating... Sheep also exhibit high degrees of emotional intelligence not clear why pork is dirty, heck even.